Toward the end of Fun Home, there’s a song called “Edges of the World.” It’s delivered by Bruce, a closeted man in his mid-50s. It’s a harrowing description of his life-long inability to embrace and celebrate his true self. Using his house as a metaphor, Bruce describes himself in terms of physical corruption and devastation. He’s “cracking, “shoddy,” “twisting” and finally, “falling into nothing.” It’s a devastating song of terror and rage at the realization you’ve wasted your life. It is also, in Rob Lindley’s virtuosic delivery, a song that will haunt you for weeks. Perhaps longer.
Based on Alison Bechdel’s graphic novel of the same name, Fun Home is centered on Bruce’s daughter, Alison. The autobiographical musical follows Alison from her days as a precocious pre-teen who loves drawing and loathes wearing dresses to a thoughtful, confident out-and-proud lesbian artist. But while Fun Home is ostensibly Alison’s story, it’s her father Bruce that shines through with the most ferocious intensity in Victory Gardens’ superb production.
Director Gary Griffin’s ensemble will break your heart with their ability to embody the characters in Bechdel’s story, but it is Lindley who delivers the final anvil blow that will shatter it to smithereens. In the 269-seat Victory Gardens, Fun Home has an intimacy it lacked when the national tour played the 2,253-seat Oriental Theatre last November. This is especially evident in the musical numbers, which often feel like they’re coming at you with the immediacy of your own immediate family.
If the above makes it sound like Fun Home will leave you popping Zoloft like Skittles, rest assured that the production is as triumphant as it is dark. Adapted by Lisa Kron (book) and Jeanine Tesori (music and lyrics), Fun Home is also consistently hilarious. The life and times of Alison and her family are hysterical, starting with the commercial that Small Alison (Sage Elliott Harper and Stella Rose Hoyt, alternating) and her brothers (Leo Gonzalez and Preetish Chakraborty) create for the family funeral (or “fun”) home. The ad has the aesthetic of a Partridge Family number, with shades of the Brady Bunch, Johnny Bravo era. It involves puppets and casket-choreography and is all kinds of brilliant.
Alison’s travails as she matures into college-aged Medium Alison (Hannah Starr) and (adult) Alison (Danni Smith) are a pitch-perfect blend of humor and sorrow, always edged by a knife-blade of bittersweet sharpness. In Medium Alison’s post-coital “Changing My Major to Joan,” Starr embodies a glorious merger of vulnerability and overwhelming, unadulterated joy. It’s the feeling of falling in love for the first time, compressed into a single three-minute song. Starr is fearless, sending the joy to the rafters. She also captures the pride and dignity that comes with love – no small feat for a scene that has her wearing nothing but underpants, tube socks and a stomach-skimming T-shirt.
Small Alison gets her big moment in “Ring of Keys,” a number that turns a banal household item into an epiphany. The song is intentionally halting, as Small Alison chokes up trying to figure out how to articulate her feelings. Pulling off those precisely positioned tiny rests without sounding rehearsed is exceedingly difficult, but Harper simply nails it. Every meticulously inserted rest sounds utterly spontaneous.
As grown-up Alison, Smith holds the show together, narrating flashbacks with the poignant hindsight that colors memory. Working at her drawing table. Alison struggles to put words and illustrations to her memories, flooded by a conflicting sea of emotions. From the gleam of an antique silver pitcher that her father bought at a barn sale, the family’s story spins out and fills in. There’s deception and denial alongside love; shards of anger spiking the sweetest memories.
In the language of pop psychology, the Bechdels are a “dysfunctional family.” In Fun Home, the more important classification is at the core: First and foremost, they are a family. Smith’s portrayal doesn’t play down the brutal tragedy that you can feel approaching like a freight train. But in her narration, you can see that family tragedies don’t necessarily define families. Among survivors, death yields healing, renaissance and even art.
Under music director Doug Peck, the Fun Home score is imbued with all the colors and emotion in the spectrum. Peck is to music as Griffin is to dialogue – which is to say, both get to the heart of the matter and make it gleam.
Rating: ★★★★
Fun Home continues through November 12 November 19th at VG Biograph Theater, 2433 N. Lincoln (map), with performances Tuesdays-Fridays at 7:30pm, Saturdays 3pm & 7:30pm, Sundays 3pm. Tickets are $15-$75, and are available by phone (773-871-3000) or online through PrintTixUSA.com (check for availability of half-price tickets). More info at VictoryGardens.org. (Running time: 90 minutes, no intermission)
Evil Dead the Musical Black Button Eyes @ Pride Arts Center – thru February 16 La Ruta Steppenwolf Theatre – thru January 27 Into the Woods Music Theater Works @ Cahn Auditorium – thru December 31 The Winter Wolf Otherworld Theatre – thru January 5 Fantastic Mr. Fox Emerald City Theatre @ Victory Gardens Biograph – thru January 12 Yippee Ki-Yay Merry Christmas! Yippee Productions @ Den Theatre – thru January 12 The Nutcracker Joffrey Ballet @ Auditorium Theatre – thru December 30 Familiar Steppenwolf Theatre – thru January 13 Peter Pan Bros Do Prose @ Mercury Theater Chicago – thru December 23 HeLa Sideshow Theatre @ Greenhouse Theater – thru December 23 The Steadfast Tin Soldier Lookingglass Theatre – thru January 13 The Woman in Black Royal George Theatre – thru February 17 Rightlynd Victory Gardens Theater – thru Dec 23 December 30 Ghosts Redtwist Theatre – thru December 10 Plainclothes Broken Nose Theatre @ The Den Theatre – thru December 15 Master Class TimeLine Theatre @ Stage 773 – thru December 9 Love’s Labour’s Lost Invictus Theatre @ The Frontier – thru November 18 This Bitter Earth About Face Theatre @ Theater Wit – thru December 8 Scientific Method Rivendell Theatre – thru December 2 The Lonesome West AstonRep Theatre @ Raven Theatre – thru November 18 Hello, Dolly! Broadway in Chicago @ Oriental Theatre – thru November 17 Hooded, or Being Black for Dummies First Floor Theater @ Den Theatre – thru November 17 WaistWatchers: The Musical The Royal George Theatre – open run Edge of Life Inglis Hall Productions @ Athenaeum – thru November 3 Witch Writers Theatre – thru December 16 Zürich Steep Theatre – thru November 10 The Artificial Jungle Hell in a Handbag Productions @ Stage 773 – thru October 28 Indecent Victory Gardens Theater – thru November 4 Tootsie the Musical Broadway Chicago @ Cadillac Palace Theatre – thru October 14 Phoebe in Winter Facility Theatre @ Holy Trinity Church School – thru October 27 Frankenstein Lifeline Theatre – thru October 28 Crime and Punishment Shattered Globe Theatre @ Theater Wit – thru October 20 The Shipment Red Tape Theatre @ The Ready – thru October 13 These Shining Lives Three Crows Theatre @ Piven Theatre – thru September 30 Borealis The House Theatre @ Chopin Theatre – thru October 21 A Shayna Maidel TimeLine Theatre – thru November 4December 2 Dec 16 El Grande de Coca-Cola Summer Stages & Waterfront Cafe @ Berger Park – thru Sept 29 Tres Bandidos Agency Theater Collective @ Heartland Studio – thru September 15 Haymarket Underscore Theatre @ Theater Wit – thru September 16 Avenue Q Mercury Theater Chicago – thru November 5 Holding the Man Pride Films & Plays @ Pride Arts Center – thru August 26 Hurricane Damage PAC Pride Fest @ Pride Arts Center – thru August 26 Defacing Michael Jackson Flying Elephant Productions @ Stage 773 – thru August 12 Sickle Red Theater Chicago @ Strawdog Theatre – thru July 29 Support Group for Men Goodman Theatre – thru July 29 Heartbreak Hotel Broadway in Chicago @ Broadway Playhouse – thru September 9 The Golden Girls: The Lost Episodes, Vol. 2 Hell in Handbag @ Mary’s Attic – thru September 7 Tilikum Sideshow Theatre @ Victory Gardens Theater – thru July 29 The View Upstairs Circle Theatre @ Pride Arts Center – thru July 22 Neverland Lifeline Theatre – thru July 15 August 12 Memphis Porchlight Music Theatre @ Ruth Page Arts Center – thru June 10 The Cake Rivendell Ensemble Theatre – thru May 20 June 2 9 to 5: The Musical Firebrand Theatre @ The Den Theatre – thru May 20 The Spitfire Grill Refuge Theatre Project @ Windy City Cafe – thru May 5 Pretty Woman the Musical Broadway in Chicago @ Oriental Theatre – thru April 15 Women Laughing Alone with Salad Theater Wit – thru April 29 May 12 Bad Girls: The Stylists Akvavit Theatre @ Strawdog Theatre – thru April 14 Why Do You Always Wear Black? Organic Theater @ Greenhouse Theater – thru April 8 Schiller’s Mary Stuart Chicago Shakespeare @ Navy Pier – thru April 15 Anna Karenina Lifeline Theatre – thru April 8 Bunny, Bunny Mercury Theater Chicago – thru April 1 April 15 Plantation! Lookingglass Theatre – thru April 22 Kingdom Broken Nose Theatre @ Den Theatre – thru April 7 A Story Told in Seven Fights The Neo-Futurists – thru April 7 Southern Gothic Windy City Playhouse – thru May 27 July 29